Ask about the caretaker
Journal steps 1, 2 · Branches may vary
Look for the concealed entry on the almshouse's first floor and push the bookcase. After investigating the closed wing, report to the deacon during the Day objective to obtain access to the cathedral library.
A Dubious Gift is a quest.
Quest Guide
Objectives, requirements, important choices and rewards in one place.
Journal steps 1, 2 · Branches may vary
Journal steps 3, 4 · Branches may vary
Journal steps 5 · Branches may vary
Journal steps 6 · Branches may vary
Related outcomes 1, 2, 3
All three investigated/reporting resolutions attach Library Key; their XP tiers differ.
Related outcome 5
If the deacon is already dead, the journal records that there is no one to report to. Do not direct the player to a live deacon unconditionally.
Search this section for the exact wording from your journal, then use the action, requirement and location notes to work out what to do next.
Branch and optional objectives may appear in a different order.
Where a step says “Marker only”, the journal does not give a fixed entrance, so follow the in-game marker for it.
A related objective target opens the objective area; it may not be the exact entrance or the NPC’s current position.
Action
Go to the almshouse.
If stuck
Action
Ask about the caretaker at the almshouse.
If stuck
Action
Look for clues in the almshouse's abandoned wing.
If stuck
Action
Push the bookcase.
If stuck
Action
Investigate the almshouse's abandoned wing.
If stuck
Action
Tell the deacon about the caretaker's fate.
Where
Follow the in-game marker.
Requirements
What may appear next
If stuck
These cards show alternative quest outcomes. Rewards from different endings are not added together.
The XP shown is the base quest reward; other bonuses or rewards earned earlier are separate.
The XP shown is the base quest reward; other bonuses or rewards earned earlier are separate.
The XP shown is the base quest reward; other bonuses or rewards earned earlier are separate.